I have been doing onshape cad for about 3 years and they don’t have a cam studio. Looking at freecad and was wondering what Langmuir or customers think? Is Langmuir software compatible with it?
I use FreeCAD for CAD right now. I’ll be trying out the CAM piece once I get my mill up and running so I’m not sure how it will go yet. I know most on here use Fusion 360 but I don’t like the fact that it forces you to store your files on their cloud.
I would like to use FreeCAD as well but I think Langmuir supports Fusion 360. The CAM in FreeCAD is acceptable but I don’t know what post-processor option to use that would work for the MR-1. I hope there’s someone on here with experience using it.
I haven’t done it yet but this was the advice I found: Post Processor for FreeCAD
@wheelz if you can update here when you do, please let me know. I have no idea how to do that stuff yet.
I can do that though it may be a little while. I’m working on welding together a custom frame (though getting close on it) and I then still have to assemble my mill. I’m just doing it in my spare time as well.
@Coyote76 I wanted to let you know that Onshape now has cam studio. We recently added a Langmuir MR1 to our list of machines and posts. If you have any questions let me know.
You can actually save your fusion files to your computer as well.
You can also delete files from their cloud after exporting and still open them from your local drive.
@Johnny_D The CAM Studio addition to OnShape looks great.
Unfortunately it being only available in expensive paid subscriptions probably puts it out of budget for many MR-1 users. This is what is on your website:
Professional Plan is $2500/year, or over $200/mo. That is 3x higher than a Fusion license that includes 3-axis CAM, and the free personal Fusion license is enough for hobbyist MR-1 users who aren’t using their machines for profit.
I’ve been using Fusion for a decade or more and am interested in OnShape, but it’s clear to me that OnShape isn’t very interested in targeting hobbyist users.
One thing that Fusion did here which is very attractive is offering per-day pricing for premium features in their Flex package. Hopefully OnShape considers something along those lines to make CAM Studio even an option that a hobby machinist could consider. It’s a good sign to me that you bought the MR-1 since that is a machine that clearly targets the advanced hobby market.
Thank you for the feedback @AlexW
I actually work for PTC as the project manager for Onshape cam studio. I haven’t purchased a MR-1 machine but I certainly would like to!
Yes, that is correct. Today we offer cam studio to professional licenses and above. I 100% agree, fusion is a great tool for hobbyists and users who are not looking for production work. I can’t speak to what will come in the future, but today all of our applications are available with a professional or above subscription.
