30k seems steep as I paid about $25k for a complete Tormach 1100M in 2018. I kept it a little over a year and sold it. It was a great machine but I couldn’t justify the monthly payment as a hobbyist. I’m not disputing that you saw that, I’m saying I question what kind of market they would have at that price. The Langmuir definitely makes more sense from a hobbyist perspective.
Valid points for sure.
To implement an ATC, the spindle would need to be replaced to work with standardized tool holders (BT30, etc.). A power drawbar would also need to be added. A BT30 tool holder is ~3" tall not including the pull stud. An ERxx collet tool holder is going to add another ~1.5". That leaves 1" or less for tool stickout if the gantry is going to be able to clear a wine rack style changer. I suppose the rack could be placed at the front of the bed to gain a couple of inches of tool stickout but that’s going to be awkward work around.
1 Like
It makes a nice thought experiment though.
Indeed. I thought it was a future upgrade project when I placed the order but hadn’t fully thought it through. Raising the gantry by ~2" should make it more viable.
1 Like
There was an ATC thread started about 8 months ago.
Is this what was meant by a wine rack style changer?
My issue with a low profile or table height changer is that it would often emerge through a big pile of metal chips. So there would need to be a method to make sure the tool holder was chip free before inserting it into the spindle.
1 Like
Check this out. Sounds really interesting and doable for non atc spindle.
1 Like
That looks very promising Speppino!!
It would be nice if it blew a burst of air before doing a tool change. My Tormach did that. That said it was more than the base MR1.
1 Like
That’s pretty cool. Uses a lot of real estate though.
Looks interesting. He says it just needs spindle rotation and speed control in the G-code, but it still seems like there are going to be some gaps to getting this implemented to work in Cutcontrol currently. Maybe if he can partner with Langmuir to distribute it, any necessary software changes could be developed.
1 Like
Let me understand this, you bought a hobby machine and you want an automatic tool changer?
1 Like
It is part of the hobby and fun to improve the capabilities overtime. And ending up spending more than a professional machine 
6 Likes
Exactly Speppino!
Hobbyists can’t have tool changers?
2 Likes
No, hobbyists are poors. We don’t deserve superior toys. I dealt with this mindset with the Haas crowd when I had a Tormach.
2 Likes
The guy 3D printed something that probably does that. I just didn’t see it used in the demo.
Probably be some limitations on tool bit length.
Everyone knows the MR-1 is a hobby mill but I bought it for it’s price…not it’s limitations. Modifications and upgrades don’t have to be needed to be appreciated. I’m pretty good with understanding mechanical design. Where I fall short is electronics.
3 Likes
I want this! Hoping Langmuir gets with this company to add it as an upgrade
1 Like
Neat idea! Doesn’t the spindle have to have CCW rotation to make this work? Does MR-1 support M4?
I’ve seen multiple versions of collet swappers on YouTube. Like the Rapidchange arrangement, the first 2 require a motor that turns both directions.
The next 2 don’t appear to need a reversible motor but the designs are far more elaborate.
According to Techniks these are the torque requirements for various ER collets.
Even if the MR-1 spindle were reversible I don’t think it’s torque output is up to the task.
1 Like