General questions for all:
What is the smallest dia tool that you are using?
And what brand are you using for the small ones? The smallest one I see in the Langmuir ER20 set is 1/16".
How are people finding the Langmuir collets? Up to spec?
I saw a post from @microarms about running a 2 flute 1/32" in the MR-1 Tool Library post, but did not want to sidetrack that discussion.
The collets that came with the machine are higher quality than the Chinese brands from Amazon, but that’s not hard to beat. lol But they look really nice, anyway.
Nearly all my small tools have 1/8" shank. I’m running these in 1/8" and 1/16": https://a.co/d/bfwrEUg
I checked run out the other day on the 1/8" on the MR-1, with a .0005" indicator, and found no perceptible deflection. Kudos to both manufacturers.
I use drill bits down to .028 (will likely go smaller in the future) and they run flawlessly.
I’m using carbide drills for circuit boards, resharps from eBay mostly. I know Harvey tool has some 1/8" shank micro drills too (down to 0.002" ), but they are way more spendy, and so far accuracy has been great with the carbide drills.
I got the langmuir ones, and then got a set of metric accusize collets which also seem nice, with a decent box. Havent put an indicator on them yet tho.
Another ToT fan
Its good to see that Shars is carrying some quality stuff. The stuff made in Taiwan seems to be of good quality. I have a manual lathe that is made in Taiwan, and it has been very smooth and stable over 5 years of use.
I have techniks ER32 collets for use in collet blocks. They seem well made. My only grip with them is that the engraving is a very light color and difficult to see.
I received a technics ER20 nut and 1/2" ER20 collet a few days ago but haven’t yet tested it for runout.
Having only looked at the technik ER20 I can say a few things.
The markings in the techniks are difficult to see, as I expected from their ER32s.
The metal gauge is obviously thinner and they seem more compliant when squeezed by hand. I don’t know if that is good or bad. I suspect the technik would have more clamping range.
The interior surface finish, purely by eye, seems to be a lower RA on the technik but this is comparing a slightly used collet to one fresh out of the box.
I was able to clamp .031" shank with my .062" technik collet without issue, and without too much effort (likely due to the thinner steel), it ran true and it seemed to spring back to size afterward…don’t know what it would do over time.
But I found a better tool, so won’t be needing to hit .031" any more, either.