Help on cutting circles (Solved)

As mentioned in title, looking for some help on cutting actual round circles.

Here is my f360 file: CircleTestPlate

I cut a sign that was 24” circle and it was all wonky and offset.
This lead me down a rabbit hole of chasing the perfect circle. I started cutting smaller circles for tests using different settings and doesn’t seem to help.

Others suggested tightening couplers between steppers and lead screws, which ive done. I’ve checked and rechecked these collets and they’re tight.

I just figured out the best settings for minimal dross, so this is my second issue to tackle.

Using crossfire pro
Razorweld 45
Machine torch
Air 100psi / 80psi at internal regulator
75 ipm
31amps
Fusion360
I’ve tried using smoothing and tried playing with the other setting for slowing down the ipm during rounded cuts and circles and didn’t seem to help. (Couldn’t remember name)

Thanks!

That’s definitely losing steps from either coupler slip or binding in what looks like the Y axis. Unless the piece has been rotated, then I would suspect that the X axis lead nut bracket is loose.

3 Likes

Those are some really nice looking lemons

4 Likes

if you say couplings are not slipping . Do you or have you used wd 40 or 3 in one on your lead screws?

1 Like

Your x and y axis may not be square to each other. Check that first.

2 Likes

I built the table back in October. I cleaned lead screws last week with brake clean and sprayed a bit of white lithium on them.

I wouldn’t be using brake clean for cleaning; it will make plastic brittle, and some will chemically melt plastic. When assembling you pro did Y and X carriage push easy by hand before installing lead screws? If not, bearings are too tight and will cause binding in spots.

2 Likes

Thanks. I’m looking at the best way to verify square now that water pan and everything have been added. It’s not obvious to me.

But in looking, I found my x-axis carriage has a bit of play where the mount connects to x-axis lead screw.
My brain is telling me that this should have play in it, but I don’t recall. Thoughts?

That mount has to be tight to carriage .

1 Like

That needs to be tight and perfectly square to the X axis rail. If it’s not tight, it will screw up any directional changes in X. If it’s not square to the rail, it will bind in X

3 Likes

Correct there should not be any play in it. Calibrating the x is very important. You’ll need to pay attention while doing it, that you don’t over tighten the bearings in one spot. You want to check the x axis squareness and bearings at at least three spots on the gantry. I believe per Langmuirs instructions, only two bearings need to be in contact at a given point.

1 Like

There was a part in the assembly instructions where you bump the x gantry into the stanchions and then secure the couplers. This is when you essentially squared the x to the y, assuming your stanchions were the same distance apart.

I can bump my machine out of square by pushing one side, and can bring it back by pulling on the side. I believe some people bump theirs out of square by ramming the carriage into the stanchions since they may not be perfectly even from side to side.

2 Likes

Thanks everyone!
I think I had an issue with it binding when tight at first.
I spent some time this evening doing some tinkering and adjusting and I’m happy to say that we have less lemons and more actual ROUND circles.
Thanks a tons everyone!!

4 Likes

Thanks. Totally understand brake clean and plastic/rubber. I was using to clean lead screws controlled and wiping off.

During assembly the carriage did push easily. Everything rolled well.

For bearing blocks, I made sure to just tighten to where there was a bearing just contacting on the opposing side. Same with tramming the carriage.