Here’s a comparison:
Same pattern (1x3, .125, .250, .375 holes), top piece is start from center. Bottom is arc lead in, no lead out. (.07" length) Dimensionally, start from center was .004" closer to true. (Arc was wider on one axis for .125" hole)
Same parts, back side, un cleaned. The arc in has a touch more dross at one side of the hole, presumably lead-in location.
Personally, they both look really good to me!