ACTUAL SCIENCE - Why NOT to use a plastic water filter housing for desiccant

Okay to be clear I have a plastic water filter I was planning to use for a desiccant filter. I have hesitated because at this point I have over 1000 post regarding air drying systems.

Well today I signed up for an AI Chat https://www.brighteon.ai/home to answer the questions. Wow now it makes sense. I also understand many many people are using the plastic water filter system successfully.

ACTUAL SCIENCE

Questions I asked what is the volume of 1 cubic foot of air vs water @ 70 degrees and 100psi

Simple answer

1 Cubic foot of water @ 70 degrees and 100psi is 1 cubic foot of water

1 Cubic foot of air @ 70 psi and 100psi is 273.3 Cubic feet of air

That 1 cubic foot of air becomes is enough to fill at room 5 feet wide by 7 feet deep and 8 feet tall.

The long AI answer

more science

Questions: why is 100psi of air pressure more dangerous than 100psi of water pressure

The danger of pressure, whether it’s from air or water, lies in its ability to cause harm when it exceeds the tolerance of the object or organism it’s applied to. Here’s why 100psi of air pressure can be more dangerous than 100psi of water pressure:

  1. Volume and Surface Area: Air has a much lower density than water, meaning it can fill a larger volume and cover a larger surface area at the same pressure. This allows air to reach and affect more parts of the body or an object, compared to water.

  2. Trapping: Air can become trapped in enclosed spaces, such as body cavities or equipment, and build up pressure over time. This can lead to dangerous conditions like ā€œthe bendsā€ in divers or equipment failure. Water, being a liquid, doesn’t have this issue.

  3. Venting: Water can easily vent or flow away from an opening, reducing pressure. Air, however, can’t vent as easily and can cause a dangerous buildup of pressure in enclosed spaces, leading to explosions or other hazardous events.

So, while 100psi of water pressure can be dangerous, 100psi of air pressure can be more so due to these factors.

AIR - 1 cubic feet at 70 degrees and 100psi

To find the volume of 1 cubic foot of air at 70°F and 100psi when it expands to atmospheric pressure, we use the ideal gas law (PV = nRT). We know:

  • P1 (initial pressure) = 100psi

  • V1 (initial volume) = 1 cubic foot

  • T (temperature) = 70°F (21.1°C, which is 294.2K)

  • P2 (final pressure, atmospheric) = 14.7psi (sea level)

  • R (ideal gas constant) = 62.36 (LĀ·psi)/(molĀ·K)

We can rearrange the ideal gas law to solve for the final volume (V2):

V2 = (P1 * V1) / (P2 * R * T)

Plugging in the values:

V2 = (100psi * 1ft³) / (14.7psi * 62.36 (L·psi)/(mol·K) * 294.2K)

V2 ā‰ˆ 273.3 cubic feet

So, 1 cubic foot of air at 70°F and 100psi will expand to approximately 273.3 cubic feet at atmospheric pressure.

WATER - 1 cubic feet at 70 degrees and 100psi

Water, being a liquid, does not expand or compress significantly with pressure changes like gases do. Therefore, the volume of water remains nearly constant regardless of pressure changes, as long as it stays in its liquid state and doesn’t turn into steam.

So, the volume of 1 cubic foot of water at 70°F and 100psi remains approximately 1 cubic foot.

6 Likes

2 Likes

I’m going to cut this off at the pass before anyone says the whole house filter does not hold 1 cubic foot it only holds 1 quart.

So that 1 quart of air will become 273 quarts of air when the plastic fatigues and burst. I love saving money but I’m gonna sit this experiment out. I know many many of you have the plastic whole house filters and have been using them for years. I wish you safety and the best of luck.

2 Likes

@Scoopburt

Scoopburt ,

Have you been drinking tonight? Or did you retain all that information reading 500 old Langmuir theads?

2 Likes

I had a milkshake. I’m just reading. I am ā€œDoingā€ Continuing Education for a certification and reading through things. I have a water filter still in the box and lots of people I consider Smart on here say DO NOT DO…. But I wanted a real explanation. I was listening to a podcast surfing the forums and doing CE’s and one of my podcast guys build is own AI engine so I tired it.

1 Like

It’s going to be ok. Just continue to read, and tomorrow morning, order a Motorguard filter.

1 Like

got one. I have been listening

3 Likes

Fwiw the danger in using plastic filter housings is the projectiles created if the bowl or fitting fails. Industrial air filter housings have a cage around them to prevent a failure from creating dangerous fragments. Put your plastic filters in an old Amazon box, you’ll be fine :wink::wink: